Saturday, September 10, 2022

Benedict Option - Thoughts

 



Have you heard of Rod Dreher's Benedict Option, in which the author suggests Christians set up communities to preserve the culture, tradition, sanity and virtue of the West, of the Church herself, in a sea of barbarism? No matter if you haven't, the idea's not new, think "righteous remnant."

All that and more in mind, we heard a talk on just this at Mission #2 this morning. Good stuff, and big thanks to our Baylor doctoral speaker for giving it. But let's get down to practical solutions. Here we are in a sea of apostasy and secularism, it's the air we breathe. And with that, we're fragmented, atomized.




Case in point. Set up your local church as a true community of faith and sanity against the rising tide of increasingly obvious barbaric wickedness. Good call, but how, when your church is spread across territory half the width of Wales, in Texas. Hardly the local solution Dreher recommends. Problem.

Solution? Catastrophe. What brought Benedict of Nursia to Monte Casino? The call of God, obviously, but also the decay, devolution and catastrophic fragmentation of the Roman State. It wasn't working anymore and, in fact, had been ravaged by war, plague and just about every other terror.




So Benedict, a nobleman, renounced his wealth and withdrew, with a servant, let the reader understand, to what became the foundation stone of western monasticism and the salvation of its civilization and faith. And my point was this. 

If we're to form true counter cultural communities it might just take a disaster to force us into it. That said, wealthy patrons wouldn't hurt.

As a doomer, I wager the former, ask the dam Monkey.

Your Old Pal,

LSP

8 comments:

Infidel de Manahatta said...

Here in the lovely city of New York in the lovely state of New York, where woman can kill their children up to and including the moment of birth and call it "progress", it might already be too late. I doubt even a catastrophe can save us.

Old NFO said...

Interesting option, could fit some 'other' things too.

Wild, wild west said...

On the one hand we are informed we are to be salt and light in the world and on the other, warned that the night cometh when no man can work. To me that means you do what you can, when you can, where you can, for whoever you can, if you can, while you still can. But the clock is running out of time.

Ritchie said...

Be thou wary of falling into the logic trap of a binary choice. Rather I say unto you, hit it like the Manhattan Project.

LSP said...

Infidel, I share your pessimism even as we fail to meet up for drinks at the Algonquin. But think, when narrative hits catastrophe, reality wins.

LSP said...

I totally agree, Wild.

LSP said...

Ritchie!

Problem? Solution.

LSP said...

That's a very good point, NFO. Read the book when you get the time, I think you'd approve.